How to Catalogue a Private Book Collection or Library

The ISBN (International Standard Book Number) is a unique identifier for books, first introduced in 1967 in the UK by WHSmith, and standardized globally in 1970 under ISO 2108. It was originally 10 digits long, expanding to 13 digits in 2007 to align with EAN (European Article Number) barcoding systems. Today, almost all commercial books printed post-1970 carry an ISBN, allowing booksellers, libraries, and readers to identify and catalog them quickly.

‍

So why isn’t ISBN the universal solution?

Because many older books, rare editions, university press runs, and privately published volumes have no ISBN at all. And even when ISBNs exist, they’re not always printed clearly, correctly, or in a searchable format—especially in pre-digital publications. That means manual lookup is still an essential part of cataloging older or scholarly libraries.

‍

How to Catalog a Library by ISBN (When Possible)

Step 1: Locate the ISBN

Step 2: Record the Metadata

When the ISBN returns results, you’ll typically get the following fields:

Basic Book Metadata Schema

FieldDescriptionTitleFull title, including subtitle if presentAuthor(s)All credited authors/editorsPublisherPublishing house or academic pressDate of PublicationYear (and month, if available)EditionFirst edition, revised, etc.ISBN (10 or 13)Unique identifierBindingHardcover, paperback, spiral-bound, etc.PagesTotal page countLanguagePrimary language of textSubject TagsTopics or Dewey classificationsFormat NotesIllustrated, large print, annotated, etc.

‍

When ISBNs Are Irrelevant: The Manual Entry Process

For pre-1970 books or rare editions, cataloging becomes a research effort. These books require manual title searches in trusted databases like:

• WorldCat (library holdings)
• Library of Congress
• Open Library
• JSTOR or publisher archives (for academic works)
• Antiquarian bookseller databases (for value and rarity)

You must transcribe from the physical book:

• Title (exact)
• Author(s)
• Publisher name and location
• Year of publication
• Edition information
• Physical dimensions (especially if there are multiple versions)
• Any inscriptions or provenance marks

‍

Example: Cataloging The Present Age by Søren Kierkegaard

Let’s catalog an example book manually:

Book in Hand:

• The Present Age by Søren Kierkegaard
• Published by Harper Torchbooks, 1962
• Translated by Alexander Dru
• 144 pages
• No ISBN

FieldEntryTitleThe Present AgeAuthorSøren KierkegaardTranslatorAlexander DruPublisherHarper & BrothersPublication Date1962BindingPaperbackPages144ISBNNoneEditionHarper Torchbook EditionLanguageEnglish (translated from Danish)Subject TagsPhilosophy, Existentialism, 19th Century ThoughtNotesPart of the "Harper Torchbooks: The Academy Library" series

‍

Time Estimate: Cataloging 5,000 Books

Let’s break down how long it could take to catalog 5,000 books using a combination of ISBN and manual lookup.

Assumptions:

• 60% of books have valid ISBNs (3,000 books)
• 40% require manual lookup (2,000 books)
• ISBN lookup and recording: 1–2 minutes/book
• Manual lookup and entry: 5–8 minutes/book

At 5 hours/day, a single person would need ~59 full days. With a 2-person team, that’s about 30 days of focused work.

‍

Conclusion: A Labor of Literary Love

Cataloging a large library isn’t just about entering titles into a spreadsheet—it’s about preserving intellectual heritage. Whether you’re a collector, an estate executor, or a curator of inherited knowledge, understanding the limits of ISBN and embracing the manual work involved is essential.

The reward? A fully searchable, organized record of your library’s breadth—ready to be stored, donated, sold, or passed on to the next generation.